Written by: Stephen Hsu

Primary Source: Information Processing

I am a Quantum Engineer, but on Sundays I have principles.— J.S. Bell

My own conclusion … there is no interpretation of quantum mechanics that does not have serious flaws.— Steve Weinberg

I wrote this paper mainly for non-specialists: any theorist should be able to read and understand it. However, I feel the main point — that subjective probability analyses do not resolve the measure problem in many worlds quantum mechanics — is often overlooked, even by the experts.

The measure problem in no-collapse (many worlds) quantum mechanics

arXiv:1511.08881 [quant-ph]We explain the measure problem (cf. origin of the Born probability rule) in no-collapse quantum mechanics. Everett defined maverick branches of the state vector as those on which the usual Born probability rule fails to hold — these branches exhibit highly improbable behaviors, including possibly the breakdown of decoherence or even the absence of an emergent semi-classical reality. An ab initio probability measure is necessary to explain why we do not occupy a maverick branch. Derivations of the Born rule which originate in decision theory or subjective probability do not resolve this problem, because they are circular: they assume, a priori, that we reside on a non-maverick branch.

To put it very succinctly: subjective probability or decision theoretic arguments can justify the Born rule to someone living on a non-maverick branch. But they don’t explain why that someone isn’t on a maverick branch in the first place.

It seems to me absurd that many tens of thousands of papers have been written about the hierarchy problem in particle physics, but only a small number of theorists realize we don’t have a proper (logically complete) quantum theory at the fundamental level.

#### Latest posts by Stephen Hsu (see all)

- 23andme - November 10, 2017
- The Future is Here: Genomic Prediction in MIT Technology Review - November 1, 2017
- The Physicist and the Neuroscientist: A Tale of Two Connectomes - October 26, 2017